Is the Disney Dining Plan worth it?

Is the Disney Dining Plan worth it?

by Mary
(Upstate NY)

I'm in the beginning stages of planning a trip to Disney World for one of my daughters' 5th birthday. In the past, I've always just added a dining plan, but this time I'm wondering if it's really worth it.

We'll be staying for 3 nights, so we'd be allotted 3 days of meals, but we'll be there for basically 5 days. I'm thinking I can budget our meal spending across the 5 days and do a little better than a plan, but I was wondering what your experience is.

It'll be just me and my daughter, and we'll be focusing more on fun than eating. I'd like to get a character experience in the mix, which I know can be pricey. I took a look at your calculators, but since I really have no plan as to what we'll be eating, it really didn't tell me much. I'd love any thoughts you might have. Thanks!

-Mary

Casey's Corner

You won't be eating at Casey's - Photo by Mike Billick

Dad's don't even think about it Answer

Mary,

I'm so glad you asked this question Mary. I've got to say you're very smart to be questioning the Disney Dining Plan.

I probably ought to say up front that Dad is not a fan of the Disney Dining Plan (unless it's free). I know I'm in the minority, but I want to be honest. I think it has diminished the quality of the food and choices at the Disney World Restaurants. I also think that most people lose money.

Disney has so conditioned us to signing up for the Dining Plan that no one even questions what they are spending versus what it really costs.

Dads's Disney Dining Plan page


For you, Mary, the real question is, will save you money if you compare it to what you would "REGULARLY" spend? Maybe yes, and maybe no.

You don't need a calculator. Make a list of where you think you might eat. Find the price of a meal. Then see what the Dining Plan would cost. Do you save money? Don't fudge, be real. Would you really order that dessert or that appetizer?

We've done the math. You have to really work to make the Disney Dining Plan save money. You have to use every credit smartly.

 

one day free in the parks

Here's the way you have to think. Don't buy a Coke with a DDP credit because you need to save that for a higher priced item. Be sure that you get the highest price thing on the menu. No, Casey's Corner is not a good choice, go to Columbia Harbour House instead and make sure to get a Lobster Roll. Oh yeah, don't use your credits at breakfast, dinner always costs more.

Yep, I know. That's way too much thinking. You just want to go, have some fun with your daughter and enjoy WDW.

Our experience with the Disney Dining Plan is this. It's too much food, it doesn't really save you that much if anything, it's a lot of planning to make it work, and tipping is inconvenient.

Dad's not a fan.

Dad's Bottom Line

Mary, don't take my word for it. Do the math. If you'll save money, go with the Dining Plan, if you won't then skip it. I'll be interested to hear which way you decide.

Comments for Is the Disney Dining Plan worth it?

Click here to add your own comments

Jan 15, 2015
Happy to read that
by: Anonymous

I'm going to Disney at the end of the month for 7 days with my family (2 adults, 3 kids 11, 8 and 6). (Yes, I'm really excited! It's our first trip there!) It was about 1200$ (CAN) to add the quick dinner plan! It's a lot of money (about 170$ each day for quick meals). I didn't take it. I decided to order water and some food for breakfast and snacks at gardergrocer.com. I have checked the menus of Disney's restaurants and food is not cheap, but it won't cost so much... if my calculs are exacts! I'll compare after our trip and tell you.
(By the way, I like to follow you on facebook and read your site! It's very usefull!)

Jan 15, 2015
No sit down meals
by: AC

My son and his family, my wife and I went last year and used the middle dining plan. This is exactly what I tell people. Too much food! At the end of the day no one was that hungry for a big meal. We never did use all of our sit down meals. So we lost money right there. We downgraded some sit-down meals to quick meals and again lost money.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Ask Dad.